
The year 1986, forty years ago, has a reputation as one of the worst years in pop music. And if I look at the chart-toppers in the UK charts, about half are songs I’ll be delighted never to hear again. But the tastes of the masses don’t define a year. It was actually a pretty good year.
In 1986, pop music was in a transition. The teen-dream acts and their fans were maturing — Wham! split up, Duran Duran were reduced to a trio, Spandau Ballet were growing up (neither of the latter two were in contention for inclusion here).
But exciting new acts appeared on the scene, led by the Pet Shop Boys. Hip hop was also breaking through commercially, with Run-DMC, Salt-N-Pepa and the Beastie Boys releasing albums that crossed over; and in the UK, the dance revolution started with house hits charting, particularly the superb Love Can’t Turn Around by Farley “Jackmaster” Funk (British readers may recall singer Darryl Pandy’s explosive performance on Top of the Pops).
The album-buying clientele had enough quality on the shelves to be kept entertained. Here we have my favourite 20 albums of 1986. As always, these are the albums of that year I enjoy the most — not the best, not the most influential, not the most notable.
Nobody else in the world will have my exact Top 20, so it is unique. Before we look at what made my 20, let’s have a quick look at what didn’t. Paul Simon’s Graceland, all debates about boycott-busting aside, is in many ways a great album, maybe the best of the year. And with all the South African musicians on it, I should love it — but somehow I don’t. I don’t like Nick Cave much, so Kicking Against The Pricks wasn’t in contention.
I do like a bit of Bon Jovi from time to time, but not a whole album of it, so no Slippery When Wet. For some reason I don’t mind Phil Collins’ solo stuff, but can’t do with Genesis, even though In Too Deep from Invisible Touch is a lovely ballad. I liked a-ha’s debut album, but 1986’s Scoundrel Days just didn’t touch me, other than the superb Manhattan Skyline.
A few albums scratched at the door for inclusion: Cameo’s Word Up!, The Redskins’ Neither Washington Nor Moscow, Freddie McGregor’s All In The Same Boat, and Prince’s Parade. The latter suffers from not being another Prince album; I simply never listen to Parade. One of these actually got bumped at the last minute when I realised that a particular album was released in 1986, not ’87.

Of my Top 20, most albums I owned at the time, so nostalgia might have blinded me to possible deficiencies on some of them. Only four albums here I got into at a later point: Van Morrison’s No Guru, No Method, No Teacher just a couple of years later, and Steve Earle’s Guitar Town much later. I knew most of Peter Gabriel’s So at the time — my friends played it often enough — and I bought two of the singles, Don’t Give Up and In Your Eyes. But I hated Sledgehammer, so never bought the LP. Listening to So later revealed to me its excellence. I still skip Sledgehammer though.
And the David Sanborn & Bob James Double Vision album I bought in 1988, when I first heard the magnificent Maputo. They feature here with a lovely cover of Since I Fell For You, with vocals by Al Jarreau.
I’m not a huge Madonna fan, but True Blue is a masterful pop album. It includes five hit single releases — and if La Isla Bonita was the last of these, then the album did something right. I’ve picked the one ballad from the set, a truly great vocal performance by Madge. It was a hit at around the same time as another ballad with truly great vocals, George Michael’s A Different Corner. The two artists should have done a duet…
On past Albums of the Year mixes I excluded live albums. I couldn’t do that for 1986, when two of my all-time favourite live sets were released: Bruce Springsteen’s Live 1975-1986 box set and Maze’s Live In Los Angeles. The latter might have seemed superfluous, coming just five year’s after the outstanding Live In New Orleans album, but Maze Featuring Frankie Beverley are best enjoyed live.
Walk Like An Egyptian puts The Bangles at risk of being reduced to a novelty act, but that would be an injustice and an act of ignorance. Even that slightly annoying song is very well put together. So is the rest of the Different Light album. The gorgeous If She Knew What She Wants featured in A Life In Vinyl 1986 Vol. 1.
The Pet Shop Boys’ Suburbia featured on A Life In Vinyl 1986 Vol. 2. That was the great “The Full Horror” remix; here we have the album version of my favourite PSB song.
For some people, Janet Jackson’s Control is 1986’s best album. They might be right: it’s one of the few albums of the year that signposted the future. This doesn’t mean that the future turned out great — Janet Jackson pioneered the endless choreographed dance interludes in dance-pop music — but for the moment, Control was a self-assured work of joy.

Some might regard The Smiths’ The Queen Is Dead as the best of 1986. I’m not among them, but I would rate it as their best, speaking as somebody who went through and survived an intense period of Smiths fanship. But the album’s genius resides not so much in Morrissey’s lyrics and vocals, but in Johnny Marr’s guitar and — often forgotten — Andy Rourke and Mike Joyce’s rhythm section.
Of course, Morrissey came up with some great lyrics, especially on the rightly much-loved There Is A Light That Never Goes Out and the beautifully morose I Know It’s Over. But then there are the stupidly-punning Vicar In A Tutu, the bile-shooting Frankly Mr Shankly, the unnecessary Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others… Morrissey wasn’t always as hilarious as he thought. Some might add the dyslexic Cemetry Gates as a crime against lyrics, but I like that one. Still, none of those are Girlfriend In A Coma, which would come a year later.
A lesser-know act here is Hipsway, who didn’t reach stardom despite my enthusiastic advocacy. The Scottish band had on solitary UK Top 20 hit, the irresistible The Honeythief (also on A Life In Vinyl 1986 Vol. 1), and four other singles tickled the Top 75. The featured track reached #55. It, and the band, deserved better. But for inadequate promotion and line-up changes, Hipsway might have become big, even without my enthusiastic promotion.
The most obscure artist here though is the excellent soul singer Tashan, and his inconspicuousness in the annals of 1980s soul is a real shame. His Chasin’ A Dream album (which I might have bought in 1987) was released on Def Jam. While it was very much a soul affair with no rapping or scratching, the air of hip hop is discernible. Disappointingly, it was not a commercially successful album. Tashan went on to release three more albums between 1989 and 2002; none of them made him the star he deserved to be.
I don’t suppose that for many people, a playlist of music from 1986 would open with Janet Jackson’s funkiest number and close with a show tune. But I can listen to the soundtrack of Little Shop Of Horrors at any time. Of course, I love the initially panned film as well — more than the stage show because I actually like the film’s denouement. Because who doesn’t like a happy ending?
And if there was only one album I may keep from 1986? I think it would be the Springsteen live box set (if that’s not allowed, I take the Anita Baker album). So, what are your albums of 1986?
This mix won’t fit on a CD-R but I’ve made covers anyway, and the above text in PDF format. PW in comments.
1. Janet Jackson – Nasty (Control)
2. Pet Shop Boys – Suburbia (Please)
3. The Bangles – Walking Down Your Street (Different Light)
4. Hipsway – Long Black Limousine (Hipsway)
5. Madonna – Live To Tell (True Blue)
6. Anita Baker – Same Ole Love (Rapture)
7. Tashan – Ooh We Baby (Chasin’ A Dream)
8. Maze Featuring Frankie Beverly – Back In Stride (Live in L.A.)
9. Crowded House – Something So Strong (Crowded House)
10. The Housemartins – Flag Day (London 0 Hull 4)
11. The Smiths – I Know Its Over (The Queen Is Dead)
12. Depeche Mode – A Question Of Lust (Black Celebration)
13. Peter Gabriel – In Your Eyes (So)
14. Bruce Springsteen – Bobby Jean (Live 1975-1985)
15. Steve Earle – Down The Road (Guitar Town)
16. Van Morrison – Foreign Window (No Guru, No Method, No Teacher)
17. Luther Vandross – See Me (Give Me A Reason)
18. Freddie Jackson & Melba Moore – A Little Bit More (Just Like The First Time)
19. Bob James & David Sanborn feat. Al Jarreau – Since I Fell For You (Double Vision)
20. Rick Moranis & Ellen Greene – Suddenly, Seymour (Little Shop Of Horrors OST)
GET IT! or HERE!
Previous Albums of the Year mixes:
1971 Vol. 1
1971 Vol. 2
1972
1973
1974
1975
1982
1983
1984
1985
More Albums of the Year
More CD-R Mixes
Recent Comments